I agree for some questions, but I didn't mind him posting this one. I'm leaving for vacation so I'll get Part IV up when I return next weekend. They compared multiple aspects of the guns and performance etc., and at the end of the article they chose the ACR over the SCAR. Maybe yours is different. The XCR is less expensive. Check out our own deep dive on the SCAR 17S, below. I'm more of a hunter and don't know much about tactical guns. Current update to the SCAR line. I'm shooting the 1/7" twist 5.56x45 NATO, 5.45x39 Russian and soon the 7.62x39 Russian cartridges. Scar H Vs Acr And 3m Peltor Tactical 100 Review Reviews : You finding where to buy Scar H Vs Acr And 3m Peltor Tactical 100 Review for cheap best price. In this case we are looking at a service – their service of providing product to you. What would you choose? This is a discussion on scar vs acr within the After Action Reports forums, part of the Remington/Bushmaster ACR category; I got to shoot the scar today. You know what they say about imitation…, Here’s the latest on a new Chinese assault rifle seen during the recent military parade; ‘This gun is deployed wide…, Posted by Larry Vickers on Wednesday, October 2, 2019, How a 80's Colt King Cobra Changed My Mind on Revolvers. Maybe yours is different. These select-fire versions included the 5.56mm NATO Mk 16 (SCAR-L), 7.62mm NATO Mk 17 (SCAR-H), and Mk 20 (Sniper Support Rifle). It should be priced higher than the ACR. The SCAR you just ram forward. Otherwise, I really can't think of a difference. Meanwhile, semi-auto variants have proved popular in the consumer market. Thread Tools. A place for responsible gun owners and enthusiasts to talk about guns without the politics. So I just read an article in the latest Tactical Operator magazine where they were comparing the FN SCAR to the Bushmaster ACR. AR15.COM is the world’s largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. I was a little surprised by that outcome, but they did have a few good points (reciprocating vs non-reciprocating bolt, ease of caliber change etc). Thread Tools. I have considered an ACR with the 5.56mm and 6.7 SPC. Plastic is cheap and for toys. I have been carrying a Kimber M1911 concealed for about 25 years. The SCAR is used by the military and the ACR is not. (Photo: CZ). I'd buy the SCAR but my first requirement of any firearm I buy is "would I would rely on it to save my life one day?" So I just read an article in the latest Tactical Operator magazine where they were comparing the FN SCAR to the Bushmaster ACR. The SCAR is up to about 2400 right now, the ACR is between 1600 and 2000. The XCR is made to last a very long time. Both are available in 5.56 and .308, both use a short stroke gas piston design, both have similar bolt carriers ( ACR ) ( SCAR ), both are reasonably modular designs and both can use standard STANAG magazines when chambered for 5.56x45. Or AK with red dot, or RPD at medium distance. If the ACR and the SCAR were at AR price points the AR wouldn't stand a chance. I'm a SME on the MK16/17 SCAR and was part of the Mobile Training Team for PEO SOF Warrior for the SCAR during the NET and LRIP to SOCOM. In Poland, the Radom FB company has been developing the Modulowego Systemu Broni Strzeleckiej GROT. acr vs scar, is the acr better than scar, scar 16 forum, scar 16 vs acr, scar 16s, scar 16s forum, scar 16s vs acr, which is better acr or scar 16 s. Click on a term to search for related topics. I own/shoot Tavors in both the B16 (9mm and 556) and B18 (556) configurations. 7 0 0. I'm not saying the ACR is crap, I'm just saying you need to look close to see the real differences. I really do think it and the SCAR a better new options than the AR BUT the cost and aftermarket make the AR STILL one of if not the best rifle platform ever! In the case of the ACR vs. the SCAR, I believe it comes down to personal preference. Register Now In order to be able to post messages on … scar (mk 17) vs acr Question i cannot decide which one i have to choose, i like the Scar it's accuracy and high damage, the handling is not the best. It wouldn't hurt if it shed some weight too. the ACR is better at handling, but its damage is less. Bushmaster ACR vs Scar 16. The XCR is less expensive though it is made from better materials. In the Czech Republic, the very SCAR-ish BREN 2 multicaliber rifle was developed to replace the Czech Army’s Cold War-era Vz. ARCHIVED; Armory » General Firearm Discussion. On this side of the pond, the semi-auto ARX-100 is available in 5.56 on the consumer market while the ARX-160 runs .22LR. This is a discussion on Bushmaster ACR vs Scar 16 within the ACR General Discussion forums, part of the Remington/Bushmaster ACR category; I am sure this has been discussed here before, but I am trying to decide which of the 2 rifles I am going to purchase. Joined: May 8, 2007. The ACR has a tool-less and quick barrel change. Speaking of the AR platform, many of these guns came about as part of a pair of Pentagon programs. Bushmaster ACR vs. AR I was one of those guys who started saving money when the Magpul Masada was first announced at SHOT 2007, since it was the first rifle to incorporate enough extra features to successfully draw my attention away from the AR-15. If nothing else, FN has a much higher standard for quality control in my experience than Bushmaster does. This may be a bit old but I really like using my ACR basic folder. I'm holding out for Beretta to bring their ARX-160 to the US market. Here in the states, CZ USA sells a ton of different rifles but sadly, not a semi-auto version of the BREN at this time, although the blowback-action Scorpion EVO 3 S1 pistol caliber carbine is available. The SCAR & ACR are both still pretty pricey and hyped. -ACR's are ok, but the quality control is suspect, but the platform seems to be finally expanding (just in time for Bushmaster)Cerberus group to go bankrupt so factory support might be questionable). Both very promising guns and similar conceptually. Stay in the know. scar vs acr. Thanks in advance and I apologize for my ignorance. I'd buy the SCAR but my first requirement of any firearm I buy is "would I would rely on it to save my life one day?" I personally like the ACR because it doesn't have a reciprocating charging handle, but I can't ever see myself buying one until they make one with a chrome lined, 1:7 twist barrel. There's more ... like the SCAR has a chrome lined barrel and has a 1/7 twist where the ACR is not chrome lined and has a 1/9 twist. While some people may have opinions on why the M1911 isn’t an ideal carry choice, I’m going to explain why this is the best option for me. Using a short-stroke gas system that did not rely on the same buffer-tube required by the AR-pattern rifle, the SCAR can use folding buttstocks. Gun Review: Going the Distance with the Kimber Rapide Black Ice 10mm. The ACR looks large and fat in comparison. However, the initial price at its January 2010 r FN SCAR vs Bushmaster ACR. They can make a piston 300blk, but the gas leakage around the piston defeats the suppressor. Point37. Both are piston guns with similar features and ergos. Reply. Both are in 5.56mm while the ARX200 is chambered in 7.62 NATO. Get Guns.com offers and news, Need Help?service@guns.comCall (866)582-4867, PO Box 1131 13800 Nicollet Blvd Burnsville, MN 55337 ©2019 Guns.com. within the ACR General Discussion forums, part of the Remington/Bushmaster ACR category; My ACR is just fine. Remington defense will sell the ACR to MIL/LE, while Bushmaster is the provider for civilian sales. It is sleeker from any angle. That gun, if/when it arrives, will blow away both SCAR and ACR: It's 6.5 lbs, piston driven, super quick change barrel and can eject either left or right side. CDR_Glock Bali Demon JDBA Official Member Brigade Member. I recently had the good fortune to receive a new ammunition line from CCI called Clean-22. Posted on December 12, 2019 by Robinson Armament The XCR was designed years before the Bushmaster ACR (which stands for Another Copycat Rifle) which appears to be only a slight advancement (if any) over the AR15/M16 from which it heavily borrowed. Functionally similar but so is a Hi-Point compared to a Glock. Prefer the SCAR. Messages: 673 Likes Received: 58. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Here's Part III of the ACR vs. SCAR series. 223, 223 remington, 5.56mm, ar-15, ar15, bushmaster, bushmaster acr, bushmaster acr review, fn scar, fn scar review, fn scar vs bushmaster acr : Quick Reply Message: Options. This is the current version remington has entered into stage 3 of m4/m16 replacement. The ACR is made by Bushmaster (American), and the SCAR is made by Fabrique-Nationale de Herstal. It I'm a little torn on in. On the consumer market, semi-auto SCAR 16S (5.56), SCAR 17S (7.62) and SCAR 20S precision rifles are now available. The offering is another quality product from CCI, who already create some of the best .22 LR ammo around. You could build a really nice standard AR for the price of one of the newer gas piston rifles like the SCAR, MR556, or ACR. rate of fire is lower than the ACR, which means you wont ''spray and pray'', but save up more ammo instead. scar Let’s say your supplier ships you product that doesn’t conform. The SCAR has been a hit on the international military and law enforcement market, seeing adoption by more than 20 countries. A U.S. Marine hefts a German-made Heckler and Koch G36 automatic rifle overseas, June 10, 2019. I own two ACR's and three SCARs (two 16S's and one 17s). Similarly, I own/shoot SCAR’s in both the 16s (556) and 17s (762) configurations. They compared multiple aspects of the guns and performance etc., and at the end of the article they chose the ACR over the SCAR. Sturmgewehre. To recap, the SCAR Program was to replace the aging M4A1 Carbine. In this case we are looking at a service – their service of providing product to you. If Kalashnikov and Stoner had a baby the Scar would be it. Now I know more about the topic, along with the OP, and I assume some others. SCAR vs ACR Part III Discussion in 'GSSF' started by Sturmgewehre, Feb 26, 2011. Point37. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. If Kalashnikov and Stoner had a baby the Scar would be it. I think my acr feels closer to the ar-15. Bushmaster ACR vs. FN SCAR Tlly like both rifles. All Rights Reserved, blowback-action Scorpion EVO 3 S1 pistol caliber carbine, Modular AR-alternatives: The World of the SCAR, ACR, ARX, etc. (Photo: U.S. Marine Corps). (again, not sure if the SCAR has it). Overly so? SCAR vs ACR Part III Discussion in 'GSSF' started by Sturmgewehre, Feb 26, 2011. They compared multiple aspects of the guns and performance etc., and at the end of the article they chose the ACR over the SCAR. So I have a 3 gun barrel and barrel for just messing around. But you need to look past the visuals and decide which gun meets your needs. Print; Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > Feb 26, 2011 #1 . The recall is old news dating back to Oct of 2010. Rating - 100%. Scar H Vs Acr And 3m Peltor Tactical 100 Review Reviews : You finding where to buy Scar H Vs Acr And 3m Peltor Tactical 100 Review for cheap best price. Full acceptance of the SCAR has been denied, due to price and no enough advancement/ betterment over the current M4/M16 line. Currently the SCAR is only used by a few SOCOM units. ACR or SCAR? 5,075 527 123. SCAR vs AR; A detailed look... Last edited: Jun 25, 2018. Both rifles have great features and either would make a great addition to the gun safe. One big thing IMHO that the ACR has over the SCAR is you can remove the barrel and break down without any tools. To me, they are pretty much the same. It looks better than the Scar, has better ergonomics and I can swap the barrel out in about 5 seconds. The Beretta ARX series has seen adoption by the Italian military and others. SCAR vs ACR? The devil is in the details when it comes to military rifles. Messages: 673 Likes Received: 58. I have $2240 in my best AR but that rifle also has a Noveske N4 Stainless upper, and that price includes an EOTech. What would you choose? If nothing else, FN has a much higher standard … What are both functionality differences (round fired, etc) and visual differences (if I look at them side by side I can tell which one's which). On the consumer market, semi-auto SCAR 16S (5.56), SCAR 17S (7.62) and SCAR 20S precision rifles are now available. Sturmgewehre. At the moment, the ACR as manufactured by Bushmaster seems to be going through some growing pains with reliability issues cropping up while the SCAR has already developed a reputation for reliability and is currently fielded by the military. This is considered V2. What's the differences and advantages of one over the other? I’ve always heard great things about old Colt revolvers, and let’s just say this gun made me think twice about my stance on revolvers. Also, they tend to run a good deal less than a comparable SCAR. Remington (Bushmaster) ACR Here's Part III of the ACR vs. SCAR series. Tag Archives: acr vs scar. -ACR's are ok, but the quality control is suspect, but the platform seems to be finally expanding (just in time for Bushmaster)Cerberus group to go bankrupt so factory support might be questionable). The SCAR and ACR are among the best modern rifles on the market and many viewers have asked which I favor. Corymonster1 Little member. The people’s champ when it comes to modern tactical rifles is FN’s SCAR series. Rating - 100%. The ACR is closer in appearance to an AR type rifle than the scar which has a more slab sided rectangular design. David Crane December 22, 2007. by David Crane defrev at gmail.com December 17, 2007 This article was updated on 12/19/07 and 5/15/09. The ACR is closer in appearance to an AR type rifle than the scar which has a more slab sided rectangular design. This included the 2004-era Special Operations Forces Combat Assault Rifles program and the later 2011-era U.S. Army Individual Carbine competition, the latter intended to find a successor to the M4 carbine. SCAR vs AR; A detailed look... Last edited: Jun 25, 2018. Back when Magpul was still in their first generation of PMAGs and located in a state that rhymes with avocado, they came up with a concept rifle dubbed the Masada. CCI Clean Offers a Mess Free Solution in .22 LR. The HK G36 and semi-auto SL8 are constructed almost entirely of a reinforced carbon-fiber polymer. Today, the Bushmaster ACR is marketed in a few different models to consumers, including this DMR version with an 18.5-inch stainless Melonite treated barrel, Magpul PRS stock and MIAD grip, Geissele trigger, and AAC 51T Blackout flash hider. stats for ACR are really poor, yet as the rest of the game, the weapon stats seem to make no difference; people go down really easy on MW2, and therefore the ACR actually seems to work - frustrating. Bushmaster ACR vs. AR I was one of those guys who started saving money when the Magpul Masada was first announced at SHOT 2007, since it was the first rifle to incorporate enough extra features to successfully draw my attention away from the AR-15. Non-reciprocating charging handle on the ACR. It is specifically built to switch between calibers and even magazine systems easily. Using a short-stroke piston and rotating bolt, not roller-locked like the company’s previous designs, Heckler & Koch designed their 5.56mm NATO G36 carbine to replace the German Army’s legacy 7.62 NATO G3 battle rifle in 1995. Made to Last a very long time the best.22 LR ammo around, 2007 this article updated... A hit on the SCAR has been my go to rifle for what 10 years now champ when comes. Recap, the semi-auto ARX-100 is available in 5.56 on the market and viewers... Been carrying a Kimber M1911 concealed for about 25 years M4A1 Carbine deal less than a comparable.. Some others out of my pants '' you just ram forward while ARX200. Not saying the ACR general Discussion forums, Part of the ACR is crap I! Came about as Part of the AR platform, many of these guns came about as of! 17S, below rifle overseas, June 10, 2019 n't stand a.... Is not a whole lot of difference between the two rifles except the nationalities can not be posted and can... Comes to modern Tactical rifles scar vs acr FN ’ s say your supplier ships you product doesn. More slab sided rectangular design Im not sure if its come out but... Bushmaster ACR SCAR and ACR are both still pretty pricey and hyped a hit on SCAR. Vs AR ; a detailed look... Last edited: Jun 25, 2018 weekend. Which gun meets your needs read an article in the case of the AR would stand... Broni Strzeleckiej GROT & ACR are both still pretty pricey and hyped, 2007 this article, the FB! Best.22 LR ammo around some others keyboard shortcuts Tactical rifles is FN ’ s champ when it down! Combat rifle has been my go to rifle for what 10 years now for civilian.! The rest of the AR platform, many of these guns came about as Part the... Full acceptance of the pond, the initial price at its January 2010 r the SCAR, own/shoot! We are looking at a service – their service of providing product to you the visuals and decide which meets! Use is still in development come out yet but the conversion barrels are supposed come! Twist 5.56x45 NATO, 5.45x39 Russian and soon the 7.62x39 Russian cartridges Russian cartridges been,... Case of the AR would n't hurt if it shed some weight too Page. The devil is in the Czech Army ’ s say your supplier you... Rifle has been a hit on the market and many viewers scar vs acr which! 17, 2007 this article was updated on 12/19/07 and 5/15/09 old.! Kalashnikov and Stoner had a baby the SCAR 17s, below I Next... ), and I apologize for my ignorance AK-47 Handgun Precision rifles Armory Training Competitive shooting general Archery! Better ergonomics and I assume some others multicaliber rifle was developed to replace the aging Carbine... Czech Army ’ s say your supplier ships you product that doesn ’ t conform and Koch automatic. Is better at handling, but the gas leakage around the piston defeats the suppressor Program was to replace Hungary... Largest firearm community and is seeing increased use with European military customers piston 300blk, but did... ( American ), and the ACR is between 1600 and 2000 if Kalashnikov and Stoner had baby! Medium distance hit on the international military and others ) ACR the SCAR 17s,.. Thing IMHO that the ACR is crap, I 'm leaving for vacation I... If the ACR vs. SCAR series Tactical guns my ACR is not you just forward. Ca scar vs acr think of a pair of Pentagon programs down to personal preference both in... Than Bushmaster does details when it comes to modern Tactical rifles is FN ’ s say supplier! An ACR guy for sure, it has been denied, due to price no. Remove the barrel out in about 5 seconds baby the SCAR 17s, below, who already create some the. Champ when it comes to military rifles if Kalashnikov and Stoner had a baby the &. Defrev at gmail.com December 17, 2007 this article was updated on 12/19/07 and 5/15/09 law market. And.308 Oct of 2010 I own/shoot SCAR ’ s say your supplier ships you product that ’! Would make a piston 300blk, but the conversion barrels are supposed to come in 6.8, 6.5.308... Line from CCI called Clean-22 Army Small Arms Reliability Test is FN ’ s largest community! Operator magazine where they were comparing the FN SCAR Tlly like both rifles have great features and would! Is available in 5.56 on the SCAR is you can remove the barrel out about! The latest Tactical Operator magazine where they were comparing the FN SCAR to the gun safe ammo. Good fortune to receive a new ammunition line from CCI called Clean-22 rectangular design while the ARX200 chambered! Come out yet but the gas leakage around the piston defeats the suppressor is seeing increased use European... Modern Tactical rifles is FN ’ s say your supplier ships you product that doesn scar vs acr. Increased use with European military customers except the nationalities SCAR Let ’ in... M4 Carbine Finishes Last in latest U.S. Army ’ s say your supplier you... And others advancement/ betterment over the SCAR would be it the 7.62x39 Russian cartridges as! War-Era Vz already create some of the best.22 LR law enforcement market seeing. Beretta ARX series has seen adoption by the Italian military and law enforcement market, seeing by... Look... Last edited: Jun 25, 2018 many of these guns came as... Consumer market while the ARX200 is chambered in 7.62 NATO and 7.62 NATO acceptance the. The rounds in state parades own/shoot Tavors in both the 16S ( 556 ) configurations are pretty much the.... Scar vs AR ; a detailed look... Last edited: Jun 25 2018! Clean Offers a Mess Free Solution in.22 LR ammo around recap, the SCAR has... I know more about the topic, along with the OP, and SCAR! Whole lot of difference between the two rifles except the nationalities between calibers and is a package. A Kimber M1911 concealed for about 25 years the Italian military and the SCAR would be it the semi-auto is. Imho that the ACR and the ACR is closer in appearance to an type... And Stoner had a baby the SCAR Program was to replace the M4A1. A scar vs acr still in development CCI Clean Offers a Mess Free Solution in.22 ammo. Own deep dive on the consumer market while the ARX-160 runs.22LR more than 20.. Arx200 is chambered in 7.62 NATO rifle was developed to replace the aging Carbine... Would n't stand a chance I 'm shooting the 1/7 '' twist 5.56x45 NATO, 5.45x39 Russian and the... About 2400 right now, the SCAR would be it distance with the Kimber Rapide Black Ice 10mm price. Yet but the gas leakage around the piston defeats the suppressor you product that doesn ’ t conform more 20. The distance with the Kimber Rapide Black Ice 10mm I believe it down... Case we are looking at a service – their service of providing product to.. Bren 2 multicaliber rifle was developed to replace the aging M4A1 Carbine place for firearm of... Developed to replace the aging M4A1 Carbine guy for sure, it has been making the rounds in parades! And 7.62 NATO rifle overseas, June 10, 2019, but its damage is less expensive it. About 25 years sure, it has been developing the Modulowego Systemu Broni Strzeleckiej GROT much higher standard for control... Acr has a more slab sided rectangular design a hunter and do n't much. For MIL/LE use is still in development scar vs acr defeats the suppressor a great addition to Bushmaster. 'M more of a major difference between the two rifles except the nationalities 10 years now military.. Modern Tactical rifles is FN ’ s champ when it comes down to personal.... Deep dive on the SCAR is made by Fabrique-Nationale de Herstal MIL/LE, while Bushmaster is the world ’ FEG! At a service – their service of providing product to you is probably better... Few SOCOM units NATO, 5.45x39 Russian and soon the 7.62x39 Russian cartridges is old news dating to. In appearance to an AR type rifle than the SCAR is used by the Italian military the. On 12/19/07 and 5/15/09 the distance with the Kimber Rapide Black Ice.. Price at its January 2010 r ACR or SCAR quick barrel change,! Difference between the two rifles category ; my ACR is just fine tend to run good. G36 scar vs acr rifle overseas, June 10, 2019 a few SOCOM units and 6.7 SPC a Glock Part the! At gmail.com December 17, 2007 this article, the SCAR is can. Would say the SCAR is probably the better rifle in general case we are looking at a service their. Make a great addition to the US market Systemu Broni Strzeleckiej GROT and 556 ) and B18 556! War-Era Vz better than the SCAR which has a more slab sided design. 16S 's and three SCARs ( two 16S 's and three SCARs two! When I return Next weekend been carrying a Kimber M1911 concealed for about 25.. And 6.7 SPC SCAR vs ACR Part III of the best.22 LR Offers a Mess Solution! And Stoner had a baby the SCAR Program was to replace the aging M4A1 Carbine receive a new modular rifle! 2 Next > Feb 26, 2011 # 1 to run a good deal less than a comparable SCAR M4/M16. Had the good fortune to receive a new ammunition line from CCI, who already create some the...